Achilles tendon rupture managed operatively decreases rerupture but increases complication .
This report has been verified
by one or more authors of the
original publication.
OrthoEvidence Journal (OE Journal) - ACE Report
OE Journal. 2013;1(12):104 Int Orthop. 2012 Apr;36(4):765-73. Epub 2011 Dec 9.10 randomised control trials were identified from the literature that compared the use of operative and nonoperative treatment for acute ruptures of the Achilles tendon. 894 patients were identified from these studies. Meta-analysis revealed that patients who underwent operative treatment were less likely to have a re-rupture (RR 0.44, p=0.002); however, these patients were more likely to suffer other complications. Functional analysis was not conducted, due to the heterogeneity of functional outcome reporting.
Were the search methods used to find evidence (original research) on the primary question or questions stated?
Was the search for evidence reasonably comprehensive?
Were the criteria used for deciding which studies to include in the overview reported?
Was the bias in the selection of studies avoided?
Were the criteria used for assessing the validity of the included studies reported?
Was the validity of all of the studies referred to in the text assessed with use of appropriate criteria (either in selecting the studies for inclusion or in analyzing the studies that were cited)?
Were the methods used to combine the findings of the relevant studies (to reach a conclusion) reported?
Were the findings of the relevant studies combined appropriately relative to the primary question that the overview addresses?
Were the conclusions made by the author or authors supported by the data and or analysis reported in the overview?
How would you rate the scientific quality of this evidence?
Sì = 1
Incerto = 0,5
Non rilevante = 0
No = 0
La valutazione dei criteri di segnalazione valuta la trasparenza con cui gli autori riportano le caratteristiche metodologiche e sperimentali dello studio all'interno della pubblicazione. La valutazione è suddivisa in cinque categorie che vengono presentate di seguito.
4/4
Introduction
4/4
Accessing Data
4/4
Analysing Data
4/4
Results
3/4
Discussion
Detsky AS, Naylor CD, O'Rourke K, McGeer AJ, L'Abbé KA. J Clin Epidemiol. 1992;45:255-65
L'Indice di Fragilità è uno strumento che aiuta l'interpretazione dei risultati significativi, fornendo una misura della forza di un risultato. L'Indice di Fragilità rappresenta il numero di eventi consecutivi che devono essere aggiunti a un risultato dicotomico per rendere il risultato non più significativo. Un numero piccolo rappresenta un risultato più debole, mentre un numero grande rappresenta un risultato più forte.
Perché questo studio era necessario ora?
Acute Achilles tendon ruptures are a common injury which can have debilitating effects on functional performance and mobility. Operative and conservative management options are currently used for this type of injury. It is generally accepted that operative treatment is recommended for young and physically active patients; however, a controversy still remains over the best treatment option. The aim of this meta-analysis is to elucidate the advantages and disadvantages of both operative and nonoperative treatments using the highest quality of evidence available.
Qual era la domanda di ricerca principale?
Does operative treatment provide better clinical result for Achilles tendon rupture when compared with non operative treatment?
- 10 studies were used to conduct the meta-analysis for re-ruptures. Re-rupture occurred in 4.31% of the 441 patients treated operatively and 9.71% of the patients treated non-operatively-, this was a significant difference between the groups [RR 0.44, 95% CI (0.26-0.74), (p=0.002)]
- 9 studies evaluating complication rate (852 patients) indicated that there was a greater number of complications in the operative group compared to the conservative group, 26.6% of 421 vs 7.91% of 431 [RR 4.07, 95% CI (1.56-10.67) (p=0.004)]
- 2 studies evaluating sick leave found that the mean time for sick leave was shorter in the operative group compared to the nonoperative [MD -23.75, 95% CI (-41.61 to -5.89), p=0.009]
- There were no differences in the number of patients who resumed pre-injury sports and activity levels based on the outcomes of 5 studies (455 patients) (p=0.30)
- Subgroup analysis of complications indicated that the operative group had a significantly higher complication rate in terms of scar adhesion (RR11.76, 95% CI (4.64-29.80), p<0.00001) (6 studies), superficial infection (RR 4.43, 95 % CI (0.97-20.23), p=0.05) (4 studies), and sensibility disturbance (RR07.53, 95% CI (2.55-22.18), p=0.0003)
- A meta-analysis of functional outcomes could not be carried out due to the wide variety of measures taken
Che cosa devo ricordare di più?
Operative treatment of acute Achilles tendon ruptures results in a significantly reduced rate of re-rupture and a reduced number of sick leave days required. However, the overall complication rate is greater when compared to conservative treatment. Both treatment methods demonstrated a similar return to pre-injury sports and activity levels among patients.
Come influenzerà l'assistenza ai miei pazienti?
Operative treatment is able to reduce the risk of re-rupture in patients who have an acute Achilles tendon rupture, but this procedure is associated with a higher risk of other complications when compared to conservative treatment. Future assessments should consider economic analyses and functional assessments to further compare operative and non-operative treatment options.
DISCLAIMER
Il contenuto di questa pagina è solo a scopo informativo e non intende sostituire la consulenza, la diagnosi o il trattamento medico professionale. Se ha bisogno di cure mediche, si rivolga sempre al suo medico o al pronto soccorso più vicino. Le opinioni, le convinzioni e i punti di vista espressi dalle persone sui contenuti presenti in questa pagina non riflettono le opinioni, le convinzioni e i punti di vista di OrthoEvidence.
0 di 4 articoli mensili GRATUITI sbloccati
